8/05/2014

"Homaje... or imitation? part 2"

Title: The house of the devil
Year: 2009
Genre: Horror, Mystery
Director: Ti West
Writer: Ti West
Runtime: 95min
Cast: Jocelin Donahue, Tom Noonan, Mary Woronov, Greta Gerwig, AJ Bowen, Dee Walace
Produc.: MPI Media Group, Constructovision, RingTheJing Entertainment, Glass Eye Pix

Two years ago I saw Alien Trespass (2009), a science fiction title where an extraterrestrial being took control of a human body, with the intention of conquering the Earth. Then, a few days ago I saw The house of the devil (2009), a horror film where a young college student was deceived and used for a ritual. Although completely different from each other, both shared to have paid tribute to a much former cinema.
To honor in this business has always been very common, as with the Cecil B. Demille award given to celebrities for their lifetime achievement.  But luckily this doesn’t only happen in such circumstances, being the nods that some directors make to their fellowmen, putting some else’s words in the mouth of their own characters, replicating their aesthetics and even their camera approaches. Any of these options would work, unless, like Ti West, they choose to completely trace a style, rather than just taking certain things.
If at its time it had already happened to R. W. Goodwin’s Alien Trespass, that this were now to happen to The house of the devil would only confirm it: these men had misunderstood what was to pay homage.
I can’t know it for sure, because both could have been made only on request. I want, however, to believe that both Goodwin and West felt, in fact, a strong attachment to their projects. Inspired to going back to that movies, today distant and boring, but great before, and from which they would both nourish.
Yet, if was West had sought to demonstrate was that the past is not forgotten, certainly to accurately copy what he’d seen in his childhood was not exactly recommended. I can already imagine how many who hate remakes wont probably even notice that The house of the devil is nearly one, blinded by their admiration to a cinema they praise, while they criticize the current one without much criteria. It’s very common to idolize the past, while the present is destroyed.
From the credits design to the close-ups on the characters, Ti West wouldn’t leave anything to chance, trying to recreate the style of the seventies-eighties terror, and even rolling in 16 millimeters for the texture. Having us seen it without any knowledge of its director or its cast we might have thought that this movie was from that era.
In The house of devil, young Samantha (Jocelin Donahue) comes across a babysitter request that will run her into the mysterious, liar and dangerous Mr. Ulman (Tom Noonan). This will receive her at his home, where he plays the needy and varies in his lies, while convinces her of that, whatever it may cost, that night her presence is required.
Sticking, without variants, to the honoree style, West would forget to include a personal and different touch. Between Samantha speaks to Ulman on the phone, goes to do her job and discovers the real reason of her stay, nothing happens that one wouldn’t be able to see in any film from the ones made ​​at that time. The house of the devil would end up been an unnecessary clone, only justifiable if it were to be an exercise of setting, done by students at a film school.
A girl taking care of someone who never sees, a house which hides a terrible secret and a couple with diabolical plans are part of a plot that, given its characteristic suspense only barely sustains itself and for a while, meanwhile one awaits to happen that original something that never comes.
If hypothetically speaking, we replaced West and the 2009 with a name and date more in line with the alluded cinema, that The house of the devil could have pass for a distant production, I think it means that today it has no place.

My rating: 4/10


Para acceder a la versión en español haga click aquí

No hay comentarios:

Publicar un comentario